| 2 Songs | Red Stars Theory | 7" Vinyl | 2 | | PBS002 | [none] |
| Mucho Cuidado | FemBots | CD | 15 | | PAPER011 | 880893001120 |
| You Forgot It in People | Broken Social Scene | CD | 13 | | PAPER001 | 623339107129 |
| Dead Child Stars | Stars | CD | 4 | | PAPER002 | |
| Heart | Stars | CD | 11 | | PAPER003 | 880893000321 |
| Closer | Plastikman | CD | 10 | | PAPER007 | 776974225922 |
| Means & Ends | Matthew Barber | CD | 10 | | PAPER004 | 623339108720 |
| Hawaii | Hawaii | CD | 13 | | PAPER005 | 880893000529 |
| Small Town Murder Scene | FemBots | CD | 11 | | PAPER006 | 880893000628 |
| You Forgot It in People | Broken Social Scene | CD | 13 | | AC001 | 827590010024 |
| History | controller.controller | CD | 7 | | PAPER009 | 880893000925 |
| Those Who Were Hung Hang Here | Uncut | CD | 11 | | PAPER010 | 880893001021 |
| I Dreamed We Fell Apart | Memphis | CD | 11 | | PAPER013 | 880893001328 |
| Touch Not the Cat | Jake Fairley | CD | 10 | | PAPER012 | 880893001229 |
| The Constant Lover | Magneta Lane | CD | 6 | | PAPER014 | 880893001427 |
| A Paper Bag Records Sampler, Volume 2 | Various Artists | CD | 8 | | PAPER008 | |
| The Constant Lover / Cheap Linguistics | Magneta Lane | 7" Vinyl | 2 | | PAPER 7014 | |
| The City | FemBots | CD | 10 | | PAPER016 | 880893001625 |
| Porcella | The Deadly Snakes | CD | 13 | | PAPER017 | 880893001724 |
| X‐Amounts | controller.controller | CD | 11 | | PAPER015 | 880893001526 |
| The Constant Lover | Magneta Lane | CD | 6 | | PAPER014 | 4024572256593 |
| Paper Bag Records Sampler | Various Artists | CD + DVD | 8 + 6 | | Paper008-4/5 | |
| Dancing With Daggers | Magneta Lane | CD | 10 | | PAPER019 | 880893001922 |
| See You on the Moon! Songs for Kids of All Ages | Various Artists | CD | 17 | | PAPER018 | 880893001823 |
| Dancing With Daggers | Magneta Lane | CD | 10 | | PAPER019 | 880893001922 |
| A Lesson in Crime | Tokyo Police Club | CD | 7 | | PAPER020 | 880893002028 |
| PF | controller.controller | 7" Vinyl | 2 | | PB S01 | |
| Night Creates | Cities in Dust | CD | 11 | | PAPER021 | 880893002127 |
| Secondathallam | André Ethier | CD | 11 | | PAPER022 | 880893002226 |
| Samme stof som stof | Under Byen | CD | 12 | | PAPER024 | 880893002424 |
| Modern Currencies | Uncut | CD | 12 | | PAPER023 | 880893002325 |
| Paper Bag Records Sampler 2006 | Various Artists | CD | 10 | | PRO-PBR001 | |
| A Lesson in Crime | Tokyo Police Club | CD | 10 | | V2CP 317 | 4520227015428 |
| Lose All Time | You Say Party! We Say Die! | CD | 12 | | PAPER025 | 880893002523 |
| Tin Fist | The Acorn | CD | 6 | | PAPER026 | 880893002622 |
| When the Deer Wore Blue | Figurines | CD | 13 | | PAPER028 | 880893002820 |
| Disco Romance | Sally Shapiro | CD | 10 | | PAPER029 | 880893002929 |
| Smith EP | Tokyo Police Club | CD | 4 | | PAPER030 | 880893003025 |
| Glory Hope Mountain | The Acorn | CD | 12 | | PAPER027 | 880893002721 |
| Disco Romance | Sally Shapiro | CD | 10 | | PAPER029 | 880893002929 |
| A Lesson in Crime | Tokyo Police Club | 12" Vinyl | 8 | | PAPER020LP | 880893002011 |
| Heart Attack | Woodhands | CD | 10 | | PAPER036 | 880893003629 |
| Earth Sciences | Laura Barrett | CD | 6 | | PAPER031 | 880893003124 |
| Siamesisk | Under Byen | CD | 5 | | PAPER032 | 880893003223 |
| Siamesisk | Under Byen | CD | 5 | | PAPER032 | 880893003223 |
| Derelict Dialect | Slim Twig | CD | 7 | | PAPER033 | 880893003322 |
| Heart Attack | Woodhands | Digital Media | 10 | | | |
| Remix Romance, Volume 1 | Sally Shapiro | CD | 10 | | PAPER034 | 880893003421 |
| Remix Romance, Volume 2 | Sally Shapiro | (unknown) | 10 | | PAPER035 | |
| Remix Romance, Volume 2: Expanded | Sally Shapiro | Digital Media | 12 | | PAPER035D | [none] |
| Vernacular Violence | Slim Twig | CD | 5 | | PAPER038 | 880893003827 |
| I Wasn't Made for Fighting | Woodhands | Digital Media | 4 | | PBR-D-1021 | |
| Remik's Cube | You Say Party! We Say Die! | Digital Media | 12 | | PBR-D-1022 | |
| Heart Attack | Woodhands | Vinyl | 10 | | PAPER036LP | 880893003612 |
| About a Girl | Winter Gloves | CD | 10 | | PAPER037 | 880893003728 |
| Victory Garden | Laura Barrett | CD | 13 | | PAPER039 | 880893003926 |
| Heron Act | The Acorn | CD | 10 | | PBRD1020 | 880893102025 |
| Paper Bag Records Winter 2008-09 Label Sampler | Various Artists | CD | 12 | | PAPER008-4 | |
| Let Me Drive EP | Winter Gloves | Digital Media | 3 | | PBR-D-1024 | |
| Life is Legal EP | Josh Reichmann Oracle Band | CD | 5 | | PBR-D-1025 | 880893102520 |
| Fall '08 Sampler | Winter Gloves | CD | 2 | | PBR-D-1027 | |
| PS I Love You | PS I Love You | CD | 5 | | PBRD1051 | |
| Viva Piñata! 5 Years of Ass-Whippin' at Paper Bag Records | Various Artists | CD | 11 | | PBSAMPLER | |
| Panesian Nights | CFCF | Digital Media | 7 | | PBRD1023 | |
| Paper Bag Records Winter 2008-09 Label Sampler | Various Artists | Digital Media | 12 | | PAPER008 | 880893000840 |
| Vernacular Violence | Slim Twig | CD | 5 | | PAPER038 | 880893003827 |
| Remik's Cube | You Say Party! We Say Die! | CD | 12 | | PBRD1022 | 880893102223 |
| Remik's Cube | You Say Party! We Say Die! | CD | 12 | | | 880893102223 |
| Dancer EP | Woodhands | Digital Media | 7 | | PBRD1026 | 880893102629 |
| Live Session | Woodhands | Digital Media | 6 | | PBRD1026 | 880893102650 |
| Two Fingers | Two Fingers feat. Sway | CD | 12 | | PAPER040 | 880893004022 |
| Shivering Black | Josh Reichmann Oracle Band | Digital Media | 4 | | | 880893103121 |
| Tambourine | Little Girls | Digital Media | 5 | | PBRD1033 | 880893103329 |
| ...at the Moment of Our Most Needing or If Only They Could Turn Around, They Would Know They Weren't Alone | Rock Plaza Central | CD | 13 | | PAPER044 | 880893004428 |
| Miracle | Sally Shapiro | Digital Media | 7 | | | |
| Miracle | Sally Shapiro | Digital Media | 4 | | PBRD1032 | |
| Hometowns | The Rural Alberta Advantage | CD | 13 | | PAPER054 | 880893005425 |
| Love in July | Sally Shapiro | Digital Media | 6 | | PBRD1035 | |
| My Guilty Pleasure | Sally Shapiro | CD | 9 | | PAPER 043 | 880893004329 |
| My Guilty Pleasure | Sally Shapiro | Digital Media | 11 | | PAPER037 | 884385793760 |
| My Guilty Pleasure | Sally Shapiro | 12" Vinyl | 9 | | PAPER043LP | |
| Instrumentals | Two Fingers | CD | 22 | | PAPER048 | 880893004824 |
| Paper Bag Records Fall '09 Sampler | Various Artists | Digital Media | 10 | | | |
| Continent | CFCF | Digital Media | 12 | | PAPER049 | |
| The Explorers | CFCF | Digital Media | 4 | | PBRD1037 | 880893103725 |
| A Way to Celebrate | Winter Gloves | CD | 10 | | PBRD1040 | 880893104029 |
| A Way to Celebrate | Winter Gloves | Digital Media | 10 | | PBRD1040 | 880893104029 |
| Continent | CFCF | CD | 12 | | PAPER049 | 880893004923 |
| Concepts | Little Girls | CD | 11 | | PAPER047 | 880893004725 |
| Contempt! | Slim Twig | CD | 12 | | | 880893004220 |
| La saveur des fruits | Monogrenade | Digital Media | 8 | | | |
| The Seven Year Itch - Paper Bag Records Covers Compilation | Various Artists | Digital Media | 12 | | | |
| Remorsecapade | Woodhands | CD | 10 | | PAPER046 | 880893004626 |
| XXXX | You Say Party! We Say Die! | CD | 10 | | PAPER 045 | 880893004527 |
| Laura Palmer's Prom | You Say Party! We Say Die! | Digital Media | 3 | | | |
| Mathemagic EP | Mathemagic | Digital Media | 5 | | PBRD1041 | |
| My Guilty Pleasure – Remixes | Sally Shapiro | Digital Media | 8 | | | [none] |
| No Ghost | The Acorn | CD | 11 | | PAPER053 | 880893005326 |
| Drifts | CFCF | Digital Media | 6 | | PBRD1050 | |
| EP | PS I Love You | Digital Media | 5 | | | |
