| recordings |
|---|
| 1936-12-09 | What Will I Tell My Heart? | | Andy Kirk and His Twelve Clouds of Joy | 3:15 |
| 1937-02-10 | What Will I Tell My Heart? | | Hal Kemp and His Orchestra | 3:10 |
| 1937-02-26 | What Will I Tell My Heart | instrumental | Art Tatum & His Swingsters | 3:10 |
| 1937-03-02 | What Will I Tell My Heart? | | Fletcher Henderson and His Orchestra | 3:30 |
| 1937-03-03 | What Will I Tell My Heart | | Bing Crosby with Jimmy Dorsey and His Orchestra | 3:05 |
| 1951-01-24 | What Will I Tell My Heart? | | Buddy Johnson and His Orchestra | 3:01 |
| 1957-01-03 | What Will I Tell My Heart | cover | Fats Domino | 2:28 |
| 1961-11-08 | What Will I Tell My Heart | cover and instrumental | Hank Crawford | 5:07 |
| 1961-11-08 | What Will I Tell My Heart | cover and instrumental | Hank Crawford | 5:07 |
| 1965-12-12 – 1965-12-21 | What Will I Tell My Heart | | Count Basie & Arthur Prysock | 2:49 |
| 1978-06 | What Will I Tell My Heart | | Ella Fitzgerald | 2:02 |
| 1978-07-20 | What Will I Tell My Heart | instrumental | Clark Terry, Red Mitchell, Horace Parlan | 6:25 |
| 1995-06 | What Will I Tell My Heart | instrumental and live | The Dave Brubeck Quartet | 7:27 |
| What Will I Tell My Heart | cover | Tony Bennett | 2:58 |
| What Will I Tell My Heart | cover and instrumental | Art Tatum | 3:07 |
| What Will I Tell My Heart | | Ella Fitzgerald | 3:32 |
| What Will I Tell My Heart | | Fats Domino | 2:26 |
| What Will I Tell My Heart | | Fats Domino | 2:35 |
| What Will I Tell My Heart | | Kay Starr | 3:29 |
| What Will I Tell My Heart | cover and instrumental | Hank Crawford | ?:?? |
| What Will I Tell My Heart | | Arthur Prysock / Count Basie | 2:45 |
| What Will I Tell My Heart? | | Fletcher Henderson and His Orchestra | 3:31 |
| What Will I Tell My Heart? | instrumental | David Sanborn | 4:48 |
| What Will I Tell My Heart? | | Andy Kirk & His Twelve Clouds of Joy | 3:15 |
| What Will I Tell My Heart? | | Arthur Prysock | 3:00 |
| What Will I Tell My Heart? | cover | Tony Bennett | 2:55 |
| What Will I Tell My Heart? | cover | Billy Eckstine | 2:44 |
| What Will I Tell My Heart? | cover | Billy Eckstine | 2:42 |
| What Will I Tell My Heart? | | Fletcher Henderson | 3:29 |
| What’ll I Tell My Heart | cover | Dinah Washington | 3:19 |
| What’ll I Tell My Heart | cover | Dinah Washington | 3:24 |
| What’ll I Tell My Heart | cover | Dinah Washington | ?:?? |
| What’ll I Tell My Heart | cover | Dinah Washington | 3:19 |
| What’ll I Tell My Heart | cover | Dinah Washington | 3:20 |
