| recordings |
|---|
| 1946-12-18 | It Shouldn't Happen to a Dream | | Duke Ellington and His Orchestra | 3:01 |
| 1946-12-18 | It Shouldn't Happen to a Dream | | Duke Ellington | 3:03 |
| 1947-06 | It Shouldn't Happen to a Dream | instrumental | Johnny Hodges and His Orchestra | ?:?? |
| 1953-12-03 | It Shouldn't Happen to a Dream | | Duke Ellington & His Orchestra | 3:15 |
| 1953-12-03 | It Shouldn't Happen to a Dream | | Duke Ellington | 3:14 |
| 1955-10-25 | It Shouldn’t Happen to a Dream | cover | Sarah Vaughan | 3:21 |
| 1955-10-25 | It Shouldn’t Happen to a Dream | cover | Sarah Vaughan | 3:20 |
| 1961-03 | How Could It Happen to a Dream | instrumental and live | Shelly Manne & His Men | 6:50 |
| 1962-02-26 – 1962-02-28 | It Shouldn't Happen to a Dream | cover | Anita O’Day & Cal Tjader | 3:00 |
| 1962-02 | It Shouldn't Happen to a Dream | | Anita O’Day & Cal Tjader | 3:02 |
| 1978-09 | It Shouldn't Happen to a Dream | instrumental | Kenny Burrell | 6:25 |
| 1998-09 | It Shouldn't Happen to a Dream | | Pat LaBarbera | 5:42 |
| 1999-04-27 | It Shouldn't Happen to a Dream | instrumental | Houston Person | 8:48 |
| It Shouldn't Happen to a Dream | | Duke Ellington | 3:15 |
| It Shouldn't Happen to a Dream | | Duke Ellington And His Orchestra | ?:?? |
| It Shouldn't Happen to a Dream | | Duke Ellington | 3:03 |
| It Shouldn't Happen to a Dream | | Duke Ellington | 3:03 |
| It Shouldn't Happen to a Dream | | Duke Ellington & His Orchestra | 3:03 |
| It Shouldn't Happen to a Dream | | Johnny Hodges, Duke Ellington & Don George | 2:08 |
| It Shouldn't Happen to a Dream | instrumental | Duke Ellington and His Orchestra | ?:?? |
| It Shouldn't Happen to a Dream | | Lucky Thompson | 2:57 |
| It Shouldn't Happen to a Dream | instrumental | Dave Frishberg | 5:41 |
| It Shouldn't Happen To A Dream | | Duke Ellington & His Orchestra | 3:06 |
| It Shouldn't Happen To A Dream | | Duke Ellington | 3:07 |
| It Shouldn't Happen to a Friend | | Carmen McRae | 3:03 |
| It Shouldn’t Happen to a Dream | cover | Dinah Washington | 2:48 |
| It Shouldn’t Happen to a Dream | cover | Dinah Washington | 2:50 |
| It Shouldn’t Happen to a Dream | cover | Sarah Vaughan | 3:21 |
| It Shouldn’t Happen to a Dream | cover | Sarah Vaughan | 3:20 |
| It Shouldn’t Happen to a Dream | cover | Sarah Vaughan | 3:17 |
| It Shouldn’t Happen to a Dream | cover | Sarah Vaughan | 3:21 |
